If you are not seeing this page correctly please click here to refresh layout



The New Zealand Herald:nzherald.co.nz


News Section Navigation

Advice from travel experts on what to see, where to stay and how to get there.

Budget not necessarily a bargain

10:44AM Tuesday November 10, 2009

Is it really cheaper to fly on budget airlines by the time you add in any extra charges?

It's hard to give a definitive answer because of all the variables (how much luggage you have, for instance, or whether or not you want an in-flight drink).

But a study done by the electronic aviation industry newsletter Flightpaths suggests the savings aren't as great as they might first appear.

Flightpaths' latest issue studies the busy Perth-Melbourne route where four airlines compete.

It found that on most days Tiger Airways offers the lowest headline fare but adds "many passengers would end up paying more once add-ons were included".

For example, the newsletter says, you could have bought a one-way flight on Tiger Airways on November 18 for A$128 (NZ$161).

But a series of fairly basic add-ons, such as paying for luggage, a meal and drinks, would bring the cost up to A$187.

Using the same parameters it would have cost A$227.50 to fly on Jetstar, Qantas' low-cost subsidiary, and A$214.50 on Virgin Blue.

But if you opted for a full-service airline, namely Qantas, the cost would be just A$208.

Furthermore, Qantas aircraft usually have more legroom than the budget airlines, but if you want to stretch out a little you'll have to pay an extra A$20 on Jetstar, A$25 on Tiger and A$45 on Virgin Blue.

Flightpaths acknowledges that if you didn't want to eat on your Melbourne-Perth flight, which takes about three-and-a-half hours, you would be better off on a budget airline.

But if you do fancy a snack then the difference between flying budget and full-service appears to be minimal. Certainly the study suggests that before choosing your airline it's a good idea to do more than just compare the headline fares. You need to think about whether you may face extra charges for checking in a bag or having a cup of tea en route.

- Jim Eagles

Pictured above: Factoring in refreshments and baggage costs can narrow the gap between budget and full-service prices. Photo / Greg Bowker

Comments

casperthedog

Howick

8:20AM Thursday
12 November 2009

I prefer Pacific Blue at the moment. I fly Wgtn-Akl every week on all three airlines. Pacific Blue has more legroom than JetStar and more than the cattle class on Airnz. Even with Silver airpoints membership on AirNZ it's luck of the draw to get in the front half of the plane where there is acceptable legroom.

Because I know when I'll need to fly well in advance (same days each week) I can book well ahead which means I hardly ever pay more than $50 per flight at the moment on any airline. But because I get cramped up in the back of an AirNZ plane and collect nothing worthwhile in terms of loyalty points I tend to go with Pacific Blue. JetStar service is still very, very poor.

Time to pull finge

Orakei

8:20AM Thursday
12 November 2009

Booked a last minute trip to Wellington over last weekend to go to the Elaine Page concert (excellent BTW!). Booked Thursday evening for a Sunday morning AKL-WLG and a Monday morning WLG-AKL. Hand luggage only both ways.

Interesting Air NZ was only $8 more expensive on Monday morning and was cheaper than Jetstar on Sunday morning by about $20. So tried both o/way to compare. On balance, nothing wrong with Jetstar inflight for a 1 hour journey but would stick to Air NZ in future because having to be at airport the recommended 60 minutes before a JQ flight (to meet 30 minute cut-off) is just a waste of my time - plus if I'd have bags to check, then Jetstar would've been quite a bit more expensive as it turns out.

JQ timetable is not so comprehensive with only three flights per day AKL-WLG. With headline stories like this you can argue almost any point of view : "Stats! Stats! and damn lies."

UnsecuredBusinessL

United States of America

4:29PM Wednesday
11 November 2009

It only depends on the budget airlines but i guess if you avail the full-service airline, at least the cost will be lessen.
Regards

generallee

Auckland Central

8:33AM Wednesday
11 November 2009

I completely agree Duncan. Looks as though they are just trying to have a dig at Jetstar.

The article refers to a rather long flight in Australia. Not New Zealand. If they compared NZ airlines they would find that Pacific Blue and Jetstar are far, far cheaper than Air New Zealand.

Yes you have to buy a coffee and a muffin if you want them but what is that? $6-$7? Still beats paying an extra $100+ to fly on Air New Zealand and get a small bag of lollies.

C

Auckland

8:33AM Wednesday
11 November 2009

In July I flew LHR to Madrid return. When I had a look at airfares I checked out Ryanair and EasyJet. The return price was around 160 pounds return. I took a hunch and checked out British Airways. Price? 106 pounds return. And I got airpoints.

Lesson learnt? Always check full-price airlines - they may be competing on the same route and may undercut the budget airlines.



Submit a comment

You need Javascript enabled in your web browser to post a comment.

Lifestyle Headlines

Previous Posts

November 2009

Budget not necessarily a bargain

10:44AM Tuesday November 10, 2009

Keeping a clear head in the air

4:04PM Wednesday November 4, 2009

October 2009

Excess baggage: A heavy load to bear

4:00AM Thursday October 29, 2009

Flying through the transit lounge

10:00AM Thursday October 22, 2009

The luck of the seating draw

7:35AM Wednesday October 14, 2009

Catching forty winks at the airport

5:25AM Thursday October 8, 2009

Just cruising: the ultimate getaway

10:59AM Thursday October 1, 2009

September 2009

A taste of Scandinavia in the Wairarapa

12:55PM Monday September 28, 2009

Twenty years off the beaten track

2:11PM Thursday September 24, 2009

Bag games: Competition at the carousel

1:22PM Wednesday September 16, 2009

A monument to love... plus ferris wheel?

11:30AM Thursday September 10, 2009

Thanks very much mate, but no tip

1:40PM Thursday September 3, 2009

August 2009

Travelling with Big Brother

1:05PM Monday August 31, 2009

Flying through the check-in process

2:00PM Wednesday August 26, 2009

Plight of the child-free passenger

11:34AM Wednesday August 19, 2009

Hard to phone home

2:15PM Tuesday August 18, 2009

Top tips for travelling with kids

11:45AM Tuesday August 11, 2009

Let's go our separate ways

2:18PM Friday August 7, 2009

Haphazard security checks test patience

11:45AM Monday August 3, 2009

July 2009

Telling it like it really is

8:35PM Tuesday July 28, 2009

Giving it your best shot

1:41PM Tuesday July 21, 2009

Making a good impression

4:00AM Wednesday July 15, 2009

Snow much fun

4:00AM Thursday July 9, 2009

June 2009

Not off to a flying start

12:00PM Tuesday June 30, 2009

Babes on planes: can it work?

9:00AM Wednesday June 24, 2009

Final farewell to frequent flyer

11:56AM Wednesday June 17, 2009

Holiday bargains at your feet

4:00AM Wednesday June 10, 2009

Winning airlines flying high

2:16PM Wednesday June 3, 2009

May 2009

A bit of healthy competition

2:16PM Wednesday May 27, 2009

More pints for your pound

11:19AM Wednesday May 20, 2009

Airport security: Keeping things in perspective

3:20PM Wednesday May 13, 2009

Beautiful Fiji: Paradise not lost

2:37PM Wednesday May 6, 2009

April 2009

The taxing business of GST returns

3:29PM Wednesday April 29, 2009

When not to make a splash

10:44AM Tuesday April 21, 2009

Technological travel tricks

2:34PM Tuesday April 14, 2009

Those magic travel moments

5:00AM Tuesday April 7, 2009

Taking to the high seas

3:25PM Wednesday April 1, 2009

March 2009

Unlocking the key card myth

2:45PM Wednesday March 25, 2009

Making room to improve

3:06PM Tuesday March 17, 2009

Less bang for your buck

8:55AM Tuesday March 10, 2009

Clever Kiwis

8:29AM Tuesday March 3, 2009

February 2009

Air points well taken

4:00AM Wednesday February 25, 2009

Give me a good snack

11:00AM Wednesday February 18, 2009

Going solo: enlightening or lonely?

1:17PM Thursday February 12, 2009

Trawling the travel net

9:53AM Tuesday February 3, 2009

January 2009

Travelling with a conscience

9:40AM Tuesday January 27, 2009

Deciding on the best direction

12:33PM Tuesday January 20, 2009

The upside of the economic crisis

4:00AM Tuesday January 13, 2009

December 2008

A leap across the ditch will do

4:00AM Wednesday December 10, 2008

History going off the rails

10:32AM Wednesday December 3, 2008

November 2008

Easing pain of US travel

9:42AM Tuesday November 25, 2008

Girls take a stand - to pee

10:23AM Tuesday November 18, 2008

Gems in our own backyard

1:44PM Tuesday November 11, 2008

And miles to go before ...

4:00AM Friday November 7, 2008

October 2008

Shop around and save on insurance

4:00AM Wednesday October 29, 2008

Holiday budgets take a huge hit

1:39PM Tuesday October 21, 2008

Keep an eye online for safer travelling

3:22PM Tuesday October 14, 2008

Cover your back - you won't lose a limb

5:04PM Tuesday October 7, 2008

Banking on the best forex deal

9:26AM Wednesday October 1, 2008

September 2008

Opening our children's eyes

9:16AM Monday September 29, 2008

A different kind of education

9:24AM Thursday September 25, 2008

Get a good deal - on cash (+graphic)

10:14AM Tuesday September 23, 2008

Holiday plans vanish into thin air

11:39AM Thursday September 18, 2008

Which way to go - buy, hire or lease?

7:58AM Tuesday September 9, 2008

Travel happily on one ticket to ride

10:27AM Thursday September 4, 2008

August 2008

How to beat shopper's remorse

9:56AM Tuesday August 26, 2008

Keeping sight of the plane facts

1:21PM Wednesday August 20, 2008

Well on your way: tips for creating a travel health kit

1:11PM Tuesday August 19, 2008

Leave your wardrobe at home

1:02PM Tuesday August 12, 2008

Avoiding airport stress

1:31PM Friday August 8, 2008

In the driving seat and set for adventure

8:57AM Tuesday August 5, 2008

July 2008

Bargain-hunting beyond call of duty

11:17AM Tuesday July 29, 2008

Getting to airport gets much easier

9:49AM Wednesday July 23, 2008

A very warm welcome home, sir

8:44AM Tuesday July 15, 2008

I'll take easy transit over free email

10:24AM Tuesday July 8, 2008

Now showing in a transit lounge near you...

9:21AM Tuesday July 1, 2008

June 2008

BA ... it stands for more than British Airways

12:16PM Tuesday June 24, 2008

As the boy scouts say - be prepared

11:32AM Tuesday June 17, 2008

Packing tips: Lighten up but don't forget the soap

1:58PM Tuesday June 10, 2008

Getting to the airport's a nightmare

12:51PM Tuesday June 3, 2008

Top of page


Assembled by: akl_n5 at Sat, 21 Nov 2009 18:58:46 +1300